Last year, I asked if the 1st print Rogues Gallery exists in a non-three hole punched version.  I got a couple replies, but I haven't been able to confirm it (i.e. find a copy).

Please review:  http://www.acaeum.com/ddindexes/miscpages/dm.html

The only difference between 1st and 2nd prints is a line of text on the front cover.  I have seen a few 1st prints, but they have all been hole-punched, and thus have never been able to substantiate the "Copies have been spotted with and without 3-hole-punching" comment for this printing.  I have seen both punched and unpunched copies of 2nd+ printings, but never the 1st.

Can someone definitely confirm this (a pic would be nice) existing?  If not, I'm crossing it off my want list and moving on.


Tangentially, I'm wondering if the DM's Adventure Log works the same way.  One of the later printings is noted as having both punched and unpunched versions, but does that apply to them all?  Or are all the 1st prints punched?  I have done a lot less research on these, due to the difficulty in identifying printings from just an eBay picture...

I think I have one unpunched.....
But there is a huge difference between thinking and proving - will have a look at the weekend.

David

Mines unpunched and was mildly excited, til I realised its a 2nd print. Sorry.  

I dunno where mine is. When I find it, I'll see.