The Acaeum Dungeons & Dragons
Collecting Forums

Travelling: an alternate vision of RPGs
Post new topic Reply to topic Page 1 of 1
Author


Prolific Collector

Posts: 205
Joined: Oct 25, 2006
Last Visit: Jun 16, 2026

Post Posted: Tue Sep 28, 2010 1:40 pm 
 

Given the recent topics on the origins of the term Roleplaying Games and Retro Clones.  I thought folks here might enjoy this bit of alternate history I wrote.
-----------------------------------

Forward to Adventure Part 1
A retrospective of 30 years of Adventure Games.
Imagination #224, September 5th 1970


Hello fans, welcome to the 30th anniversary of the Adventure Game. It was at ChiCon I where Paul Miller and V. Wiseman introduced Travelling, Your adventures in the future. Surprisingly the first edition of Travelling wasn't a game. Sure many of the today's rules were present. World & creature creation, starship construction were present. The remaining rules were either non-existent or only presented in the sketchiest of outlines.

To understand why Travelling was written. We need to go back to the New York World Fair and the first Worldcon. Miller was one of those attending the first con. Like other fans he was intensely interested in the new style of science fiction being written in Astounding and other magazines. He wanted to learn how to write these stories himself. It was said that he spent much of the convention cornering Campbell and other editors with questions on how to write good science fiction.

Miller left the first WorldCon very frustrated as he felt that nobody could give him a clear answer to his questions. He returned to his hometown of Chicago where two month later he was talking to his friend Victor Wiseman. Wiseman was studying physics at the University of Chicago at the time. Inspired by his friend's troubles, he sat down and wrote up a set of tables for his friend to use to create his stories. For the next four months Wiseman researched the available literature on planets, stars, rockets, and even a little biology. By the spring of 1940 he had over two dozen pages of tables, charts, and notes for Miller.

Miller loved what Wiseman had done and immediately used them to create his own worlds and settings pulling material from E.E. Smith and other writers of the time. When Miller found something that wasn't clear or difficult to use, he made notes and worked with Wiseman to make the charts easier to use. One innovation that introduced at this time was the use of dice to randomize various results.

Miller wrote in Imagination #64,

I was making the first sector of the Spinward Republic and starting to get repetitive in how my worlds were turning out. To give my head a break I started rolling dice to randomly pick items off of the tables, modifying the more outlandish results. When I showed Wiseman what I was doing, he picked up on it right away. He knew quite a bit about statistics and probability from his work at the University. For the third revision he reorganized the tables so you could use 1 or more dice to roll for the results.


At the end of the spring term, Miller and Wiseman had what would be the first edition of Travelling finished. With the second World Con coming in September, the pair decided to spend $100 and print their charts and notes as a small book and sell it at the Con. They figured that there were other writers had the same problems as Miller did and Travelling would sell.

So that summer, Miller took all of Wiseman's notes and charts and typed them up. To Wiseman's star, world, creatures, and starship charts, he added chapters on characters, equipment, and mileau. At the end he included a small subsector of his Spinward Republic setting, the classic Victoria Subsector.

When September rolled around, Miller went to the WorldCon and set up a table with 100 copies of Travelling for sale for $2. Travelling was a hit! With all 100 copies sold out by the end of the second day. Years later Robert Heinlein wrote

I walked by and saw Miller there with a crowd of people. I picked a copy of Travelling. Now I knew a lot of what Wiseman and Miller wrote and had the reference books; but it was nice to have it all in one place. Plus being able to use dice helped when you are stuck trying to figure out exactly what a place looked like.


Miller left the convention with orders for two dozen more books. In addition he used some of the cash to pay for ads in next month's issue of Astounding and other magazines. When he got back he split the profits with Wiseman and the two ordered 100 more books. Throughout that first year Travelling was reprinted two more times. The third print run was 200 copies and the fourth was 500 copies.

The next major step in Travelling evolution were Chadwick's famous "Bottle Caps" rules. Named for the use of bottle caps to represent starships and people. This first appeared in the March 1941 issue of Astounding, John Chadwick came up with a set of rules, using dice, to resolve combat using the starships and personal weapons listed in Travelling. Miller, immediately like the "bottle caps" rules. He contacted Chadwick and was able to get permission to incorporate them into the 2nd edition of Travelling.

The 2nd edition was released the fall of 1941 at the third WorldCon in Denver with a modified version of Chadwick's rules incorporated. 2nd edition included chapters on characters, combat, worlds, stars, creatures, equipment, and starships. Over a 1000 copies were made and all were sold within months.

The 2nd edition was the first that could be played as a game. Although the characters and the equipment lists were much cruder than subsequent editions. The second edition increased Travelling popularity throughout World War 2 .

After the 2nd Edition was released, Campbell at Astounding Magazine was inundated with submissions based on Travelling. Some were little more than lists randomly generated from the charts in Travelling. Campbell founded a new bi-monthly magazine called Imagination, Gateway to the Future and filled it with Travelling submissions. The first issue featured Miller's Spinward Republic outlining a complete sector done in the Travelling format.

Next…
Travelling and World War 2.
Travelling 3rd Edition
How Pirates & Plunder almost sank Adventures Games in the 50s
Spy versus Spy and revival of Adventure Games in the 60s.
The triumph of the Hobbit, Adventure Games return to the past and fantasy.
The Future of Adventure Games.


Last edited by robertsconley on Tue Sep 28, 2010 1:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
  


Prolific Collector

Posts: 205
Joined: Oct 25, 2006
Last Visit: Jun 16, 2026

Post Posted: Tue Sep 28, 2010 1:44 pm 
 

Forward to Adventure Part 2
A retrospective of 30 years of Adventure Games.
Imagination #225, October 6th 1970


Travelling and World War 2.

Travelling 2nd edition became a minor hit during World War as entertainment for soldiers. Especially in 1943 when Saul Banner submitted the idea to Imagination of using a single referee to judge the scenario for a group of player working together. This article came with the classic scenario Output Alpha, which featured the famed Nostradamus Bugs.

Saul Banner went on to write several more classic scenarios, notably the Memory of Beta, about a sentient ship, and Gamma Twilight which took placed on the tidelocked world of Gamma in the Victoria Subsector. Gamma Twilight was written in conjunction with Miller's article on the Aryan Consulate. The Aryanites were the main villains of the scenario.

Towards the end of the war, several companies came out with their own adventure games, but most were poorly put together in rules and binding. Travelling kept its dominance.

After the 2nd Edition V. Wiseman stopped contributing to Travelling. He graduated from the University of Chicago, and went to work for the Manhattan Project.

During the war, Imagination introduced the Aryan Consulate the sworn enemy of the Spinward Republic. Also the Dogmen of Antares made their first appearance, along with the master intriguers the Ceti Octopiods.

Travelling 3rd Edition

After the end of the War, the WorldCons were resumed starting in the fall of 1946. Miller, with backing from Campbell, hired Saul Banner and formed AGW, Adventure Games Workshop. In 1947 the two released Travelling 3rd Edition. This edition completed Travelling's transformation from a writer's aide to a full fledged Adventure Game.

How Pirate & Plunder almost sank Adventures Games in the 50s

During the war, rivals of Astounding, and even comic book companies put out knocks off of Travelling. Most of them were poorly written, poorly designed, and poorly bound. Travelling wasn't that much better but Miller used what resources he had to make Travelling the best product he could.

Most of the World War 2 Era Adventure Games were space related. Amazing Planetary Adventures, TriPlanetary (later sued by E.E. Smith), Astonishing Space Adventures were some of them. The remaining half dozen expanded Adventure Games into new genres, superheroes mostly, but there was a western (Tombstone Tales), a Three Musketeers game (Legends of the Rapier), several Pirate games, a game based on the Greek Myths, and one Time Travel game from Educational Comics (Time Travel Tales or TTT)

When EC Comics founder, Max Gaines died in 1947, his son William took over. William Gaines decided to jettison the comics and focus on taking the Adventure Game market away from AGW. He hired many of the best sci-fi and genre writers from Astounding rivals and turned them loose.

The result was an explosion of titles, and magazines for the Adventure Games market. Time Travel Tales was cleaned up and the Time Patrol was created along with their arch enemy the evil Denebians. Galaxy Trek was created to go head to head with Travelling. Their most popular game was Pirates & Plunder, a game dealing with the pirate genre. With the Adventure Games expansion the company changed it name to Entertaining Games.

By 1950, Entertaining Games was still second place to AGW. In the fall of 1950, The 2nd edition of Pirates & Plunder was released. It added a chapter on the dead, pirate curses, and black magic. This caused an explosion of interest in Pirates & Plunder and for a brief time in 1951 it outsold Travelling.

During the early 1950's Entertaining Games introduced the standalone scenario. Previously scenarios were only published in one of the magazines devoted to Adventure Games. It also introduced the idea of expansions with the release of Tales from Davy Jones' Locker. Davy Jones' expanded the chapter on the dead, curses, and black magic. This was followed up in 1953 with Legends of the Ancient Mariner.

The year 1953 was the highpoint of Entertaining Games. In 1954 Seduction of Youth was published which criticizes Adventure Games and Entertaining Games in particular. Sales plummeted and with the bankruptcy of Entertaining Games' distributor in 1956, William Gaines ceased publishing everything except for a humor magazine known as Crazy.

During this Miller and Banner kept toiling away at AGW. Despite the competition from Entertaining Games, the general Adventure Game market boomed during the early 50s and AGW expanded to a dozen employees. Miller and Banner released a 4th edition of Travelling. The 4th edition was noted for the introduction by Physicist V. Wiseman, who also contributed charts and notes on on Nuclear technology. Miller also began publishing standalone scenarios and supplements. Mostly repackaging earlier contributions to Imagination, updated for 4th edition.

With Seduction of Youth and subsequent downturn, AGW was forced to let most of employees go by 1956. Miller writes.

The summer of 1957 was pretty bleak. We were down to myself, Banner, and our secretary/office manager Lauren Smith. That fall We had a small uptick in sales from some tie ins with the International Geophysical Year. Grand Survey was the best of that year's releases. We knew that there was work being done to launch something into space.


Miller continues

By October I was working on some stuff about the early days of the Spinward Republic and thinking about how to incorporate what was going on. When Saul runs in and tells me to turn on the radio. That when I heard beeping of Sputnik and the report that the Russians launched the first satellite. I was mad and afraid along with the rest of the country. As beloved as the Spinward Republic was, this was real and the Russians were first. But inside I also knew that beep was the sound that AGW was going to be saved.


Spy versus Spy and revival of Adventure Games in the 60s.

With the launch of Sputnik, interest in Travelling and Adventure Games exploded. Even with rivals putting out their own space related Adventure Games, AGW remained the largest publisher of Adventure Games.

The closest rival to AGW was Jackson Games of Tulsa Oklahoma. John Jackson gained noticed by writing for several of AGW's rivals. His work pushed the conventions of the space adventure games in new directions. Following the strange disappearance of Arc Johnson of Small Box Games. Jackson returned to his home in Tulsa Oklahoma and founded Jackson Games. He developed Spy versus Spy in 1963. Capitalizing on cold war tensions and the popularity of spy films and shows. Spy versus Spy and its line of scenarios and supplements became the #2 game of the 60's.

The triumph of the Hobbit, Adventure Games return to the past and fantasy.

In the fall of 1955, the third volume of J.R.R. Tolkien's epic Lord of the Rings was released. With the decline of Adventure Games due to Seduction of the Innocent both AGW and Entertaining Games did not notice the release. After the launch of Sputnik, the Adventure Games Industry focused on space.

In 1963, Gary Ganon and Robert Arendt founded Fantasy Adventures, Inc in Great Britain. They loved Travelling, Adventure Games, and Tolkien. With a desire to enter Tolkein's world. Arendt created a thinly disguised version of Middle Earth called the Wilderlands and Ganon created rules for the game. The two released Fellowship, Adventures of Fantasy, at the 1964 World Con.

The game was a hit. Lord of the Rings was beginning it's rise in popularity and people wanted to use Adventure Games to play in Tolkien's world. In 1965 Tolkien wrote to Ganon and Ardent praising their work and noting that they seemed to have lost his check in the mail. Fantasy Adventures started paying Tolkein a royalty and secured an official license to continue Fellowship. Arendt then created a line of "official" Middle Earth expansions along with continuing the Wilderlands. By 1967, Fellowship and Fantasy Adventures, Inc were the #2 company behind Travelling and AGW, Jackson Games and Spy Versus Spy remains a solid #3.

During the late 60's Travelling and Adventure Games gained mainstream notice with the success of Star Travels. Gene Roddenberry, the producer and creator of Star Travels, was introduced to Adventure Games when he was writing westerns for TV in the 50's. He learned about Travelling and was inspired to combine his work on westerns with the ideas found in Travelling. Today Star Travel is in its 5th season with Jeffery Hunter playing the role of the starship Enterprise's captain James Pike. The Klingon Leonoids are a homage to Travelling's Dogmen of Antares.

The Future of Adventure Games.

Today, in 1970, Adventure Games still is a strong vital market. The recent unpopularity of the Vietnam War appears to having having an effect on sales of Travelling and Spy vs Spy. However Fellowship keeps growing in popularity every year.

Fantasy Adventures newly established line of Mines and Caverns scenarios are especially popular. It is rumored that the Third Edition of Fellowship is going to make a Mine crawl the centerpiece scenario rather than the Citadel of Dun Arthanc.

There are also rumors that Jackson Games is expanding the rules used in Spy vs Spy to the Fantasy Genre. The new system is supposedly going to be called GUAG or Generic Universal Adventure Game and involve the use of the different polyhedral dice being used in the wargames industry.

  

User avatar

Long-Winded Collector

Posts: 3153
Joined: Nov 21, 2005
Last Visit: Feb 05, 2016
Location: UK

Post Posted: Fri Oct 01, 2010 12:35 pm 
 

That was fun (as was playing "spot the reference"): thank you, Rob!

I can see a letter being sent to the editor (voice?) of Imagination, however, to complain that the article's focus is exclusively on "adventure games" and genres within the English language cultural mainstream. Spanish speakers are touchy on such matters since they believe that the legacy of their own narrative role-assumption rules "Senderos Bifurcan", first published in 1942, represents the true direction of Miller's original intention rather than the "game" such as it eventually emerged in English-speaking countries.
Oh, and didn't Prohías sue, as well as the doughnut man? :)

It is noteworthy that many such alternate events/histories could so easier have happened. SF & space gaming was more popular than fantasy in the US for almost the entire timeframe in question. Similarly, formalised LARPing could so easily have spun off (to be popularised later by the SCA ;)) from either actual history or your alternate timeline from the Norwescon WorldCon in 1950 courtesy of Phil Barker. etc., etc.


"7.3 ORGANIZING THE PARTY: Always have a keg, even if it's BYOB...
7.4 TAKING THE GAME SERIOUSLY: Don't"

  


Prolific Collector

Posts: 205
Joined: Oct 25, 2006
Last Visit: Jun 16, 2026

Post Posted: Sat Oct 02, 2010 8:01 pm 
 

faro wrote:That was fun (as was playing "spot the reference"): thank you, Rob!


Thanks appreciate the compliment. It was lot of fun to write.

faro wrote:I can see a letter being sent to the editor (voice?) of Imagination, however, to complain that the article's focus is exclusively on "adventure games" and genres within the English language cultural mainstream. Spanish speakers are touchy on such matters since they believe that the legacy of their own narrative role-assumption rules "Senderos Bifurcan", first published in 1942, represents the true direction of Miller's original intention rather than the "game" such as it eventually emerged in English-speaking countries.

Oh, and didn't Prohías sue, as well as the doughnut man? :)


I assumed that Spy vs Spy title got butterflied away. Prohias probably would have done something similar with Crazy.  

Joe vs Ivan  - A beloved comic debuted in the humor magazine Crazy in the late 50's. A wordless comic depicting two cold war soliders and their various plots as they guard the Iron Curtain against one another.

  

User avatar

Long-Winded Collector

Posts: 3153
Joined: Nov 21, 2005
Last Visit: Feb 05, 2016
Location: UK

Post Posted: Mon Oct 04, 2010 10:28 pm 
 

robertsconley wrote:Joe vs Ivan  - A beloved comic debuted in the humor magazine Crazy in the late 50's. A wordless comic depicting two cold war soliders and their various plots as they guard the Iron Curtain against one another.

*g*

I wonder if he'd've changed their hats any for that? :)
Can float quite a bit in both time and geography and was still as fresh in the late 80s as the early 60s (alas).

robertsconley wrote:Thanks appreciate the compliment. It was lot of fun to write.

Glad you did, thanks!

Well, after another few thousand pages of reading and re-reading at the weekend; yep, your alternate history might've been even closer than you thought.
Maybe if they hadn't banned Donald Wollheim from the first WorldCon, since it was interesting to read that he not only collected minis/models, but to see his left-field question on Buck Rogers models made by Britain's under license for the US market in the late 30s that he'd noticed in the shops at the time. Would've been easy enough to ask about what use those might be at the con if he'd been there. ;)

Closer to the "actual" timeline, the number of "near misses" in late 40s/early 50s UK wargaming is frustrating: pretty much all it needed was that change to "immediate" first person perspective(s). There was still RPing, though.


"7.3 ORGANIZING THE PARTY: Always have a keg, even if it's BYOB...
7.4 TAKING THE GAME SERIOUSLY: Don't"

  


Active Collector

Posts: 13
Joined: Dec 10, 2009
Last Visit: Jul 01, 2013

Post Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 6:36 pm 
 

Nice piece Robert. I didn't get the alternate history part at first and you blew my mind. I kept thinking 'had Traveller evolved from this earlier game with Miller's and Wiseman's kids taking over?' Anyway, thanks for the entertainment!

 WWW  

User avatar

Long-Winded Collector

Posts: 3153
Joined: Nov 21, 2005
Last Visit: Feb 05, 2016
Location: UK

Post Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 7:12 pm 
 

@Northwest. Agreed! Let's just wait to see when any "facts" from this thread creep in to Wikipedia... :)

@Robert: One further question I had that was ticking over in the back of my mind was why you apparently casually mentioned the 1939 New York World's Fair without noting any further details.
*
I had to backtrack a bit further, but I'll take a punt that what the official history doesn't mention is that Miller might've been talking with Norman Bel Geddes (designer of the Futurama exhibit and case for the Mark I Computer, later ^^ ). Rather slinky if so, since in addition to his design and diorama work Bel Geddes created a grand-scale wargame earlier in the decade - described in a 1933 magazine article - and I'm willing to bet that some of those ideas might've been ticking over at the back of Miller's mind in combination with those general futuristic thoughts and mentioned in passing (casually, even) to Wiseman.
If so, was there never even a hint of a court case or was such possible inspiration deemed too remote to be pursued?

^^ The above is true, btw. ;) Well, the true bits are, anyhow!
Come to think of it, was there not originally a dragon-like race called the Melanchthon? *g*


"7.3 ORGANIZING THE PARTY: Always have a keg, even if it's BYOB...
7.4 TAKING THE GAME SERIOUSLY: Don't"

  

User avatar

Grandstanding Collector
Acaeum Donor

Posts: 6720
Joined: Jul 16, 2005
Last Visit: Sep 30, 2022

Post Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 11:41 pm 
 

OK - I'll say it:

What?  Please explain.


"But I have watched the dragons come, fire-eyed, across the world."

  


Sage Collector

Posts: 2554
Joined: Jul 25, 2007
Last Visit: Jan 06, 2024
Location: Far Harad, Texas

Post Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 4:44 am 
 

faro wrote:you apparently casually mentioned the 1939 New York World's Fair without noting any further details.


Good point, since H. H. Holmes' Call of Cthulhu LARP campaign at the 1893 Chicago World's Fair was so crucial to the early growth of our hobby, particularly in light of his use of non-euclidean architecture.

  


Prolific Collector

Posts: 205
Joined: Oct 25, 2006
Last Visit: Jun 16, 2026

Post Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 7:59 am 
 

faro wrote: Rather slinky if so, since in addition to his design and diorama work Bel Geddes created a grand-scale wargame earlier in the decade - described in a 1933 magazine article -


Remember what Miller (with Wiseman) was doing was creating a writer's reference for sci-fi authors. The game didn't get put in until Chadwick's Bottle cap rules got adopted. Even then it was more of a wargame and it took a later leap with Banner's refereed scenarios before it was anything like the RPG today. Prior to Banner's innovation it was more like playing Traveller's Snapshot and Mayday.

I setup it up like that because the idea of wargames wasn't as evolved as it was by the late 60s.  The development from writer aide to adventure game (i.e. RPGs) was drawn out through the 40's.

  


Prolific Collector

Posts: 205
Joined: Oct 25, 2006
Last Visit: Jun 16, 2026

Post Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 8:02 am 
 

Northwest wrote:Nice piece Robert. I didn't get the alternate history part at first and you blew my mind. I kept thinking 'had Traveller evolved from this earlier game with Miller's and Wiseman's kids taking over?' Anyway, thanks for the entertainment!


Thanks and appreciate the compliment. Over on the Alternate History forum (http://www.alternatehistory.com) the best Alt History stories try to pull you into their setting. One of the better ones is Decades of Darkness (http://decadesofdarkness.alternatehistory.com/ about a United States where the slave states dominated the union. The point of departure is the death of Thomas Jefferson at the tail end of his 2nd term.

  

User avatar

Long-Winded Collector

Posts: 3153
Joined: Nov 21, 2005
Last Visit: Feb 05, 2016
Location: UK

Post Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 1:22 pm 
 

robertsconley wrote:Remember what Miller (with Wiseman) was doing was creating a writer's reference for sci-fi authors. The game didn't get put in until Chadwick's Bottle cap rules got adopted.

*nods*. Hence the nod to Borges-derived narrativism above being seen by some as closer to the true direction "intended" by Miller, rather than the fork in the path that was actually taken. ;)

Difficult to know when the writer's aide stops and the roleplaying starts sometimes, though (one for the Brontë sisters?): does the game drive the narrative or vice versa, and how far can one roleplay without gaming? (Oh boy, did Shakespeare hate those LARPers in his Troupe :lol:).

robertsconley wrote:I setup it up like that because the idea of wargames wasn't as evolved as it was by the late 60s.

On the prime timeline, y'mean? :)
More wargamers, perhaps (and it did almost require a Martin Padway at some points); more evolved wargaming - by which y'mean closer to RPGs? - not so obvious, especially to those following the "standard" histories.

Great innovations don't require large numbers: if anything those can actually hinder "progress"/"evolution".

robertsconley wrote:The development from writer aide to adventure game (i.e. RPGs) was drawn out through the 40's.

Thus, by going slowly we actually get to the end result more quickly. Strange, isn't it? ^^

Cheers,
David.


"7.3 ORGANIZING THE PARTY: Always have a keg, even if it's BYOB...
7.4 TAKING THE GAME SERIOUSLY: Don't"

  
Post new topic Reply to topic Page 1 of 1